هل فيلم الام المسيح معادٍ للصهيونية كما قال وكيل السستاني في الكويت المهري ؟

[ابوقيس]

السلام عليكم ورحمة الله وبركاته
أثار فيلم الام المسيح ضجة عندما قرب عرض الفيلم وبدا كأن منتج ومخرج الفيلم يتحدى اليهود وبعض النقاد العرب كتبوا وقالوا ان ميل جبسون كتب شهادة وفاته فنياً حتى وصل الامر بوكيل كبير مراجع الشيعة علي السيستاني في الكويت محمد باقر الموسوي المهري بمطالبته وزارة الاعلام الكويتية السماح بعرض فيلم آلام المسيح لفضح جرائم اليهود والصهاينة حسب قوله . وسمحت بعض الدول العربية بعرض الفيلم.
ولكن دعنا ننقل وجهة نظر كاتب امريكي شاهد الفيلم ونرى هل هذا الادعاء صحيح :-


يتسائل ريشارد كورليس في في مجلة التايم عدد 2004\3\1 هل الفيلم معادٍ لليهودية ؟
حسناً السؤال يعتمد على أي يهودية نقصد ؟ بدءاً من ((السانهدريم)) مجلس الحاخامات الذي وجد المسيح مذنباً بخرق قانون المعبد وسلمه الى السلطات الرومانية ولكن الحاخامات لديهم اسبابهم لانهم راوا ان ادعاء المسيح بانه المسايا المخلّص وقوله لاتباعه انهم سيعيشون الى الابد اذا اكلوا من لحمه وشربوا من دمه .
الفيلم يصور الحاخامات بانهم انقياء عقدياً ودينياً لكنهم فاسدون سياسياً .
ولكن ميل جبسون ايضاً صور العديد من اليهود يعاملون المسيح بلطف واحسان لذلك يمكن وصف الفيلم بانه معادٍ للسانهدريم اما وصف الفيلم بانه معادٍ للسامية فهو كوصف معارضي ادارة بوش بانهم معادون لامريكا . انتهى
الجدير بالذكر ان ميل جبسون اختار ممثلة يهودية رومانيةهي مايا مورجنسترن((Maia Morgenstern )) لتقوم بدور مريم العذراء !!!!!!
ولاأدري كيف يستعين بممثلة ترى حسب عقيدتها ان مريم العذراء زانية وان المسيح ولد زنا .
مايا مورجنسترن توصف بانها ابنة احد الناجين من معسكرات العمل في عهد النازية والستالينية وتقول انها فخورة بلعب دور مريم العذراء في فيلم الام المسيح.
وهي تعتبر نفسها يهودية تقية وورعة وتتردد بانتظام على الكنيس اليهودي منذ كان عمرها 15 عاماً وتقول انها تعشق صوت اللغة العبرية .
وعندما سئلت اذا كانت قد سمعت بالتعليقات المنسوبة الى ميل جبسون بان الهود العلمانيون المعاصرون يحاولون القاء اللوم على الكنيسة الكاثوليكية كسبب في مجازر الهولوكوست(( التي يقول اليهود انها حدثت في عهد هتلر )) قالت مايا مورجنسترن انها لم تسمع ميل جبسون يقول بهذا الكلام .
وعندما سئلت عن سبب لعبها دور مريم العذراء قالت :- حسب علمي ان مريم العذراء يهودية لذلك اعتقد ان هذا طبيعي جداً .

اذن اترك لكم التعليق على الموضوع اعلاه ونعرض قائمة باسماء بعض الممثلين اليهود في امريكا والغرب والذي لم يظهر اسمه في هذه القائمة لا يدل على انه غير يهودي.:-

Jay Adler
Luther Adler
Stella Adler
Jason Alexander
Woody Allen (Allen Koenigsberg)
Ed Ames (Urick Ames)
Morey Amsterdam
Shiri Appleby
Allen Arbus
Adam Arkin
Alan Arkin
Bea Arthur (Bernice Frankel)
Ed Asner
Lauren Bacall (Bette Perske)
Barbara Bain (Millicent Fogel)
Jon Robin Baitz
Lenny Baker
Bob Balaban
Barbara Barrie
Richard Benjamin
Jack Benny (Jack Kubelsky)
Milton Berle (Mendal Berlinger)
Jeannie Berlin
Hershel Bernardi
Sarah Bernhard
Theodore Bikel
Joey Bishop (Joseph Abraham Gottlieb)
Mel Blanc (Melvin Jerome Blanc)
Yasmine Bleeth
Claire Bloom
Victor Borge (Borge Rosenbaum)
Tom Bosley
David Brenner
Felix Bressart
Fanny Brice (Fanny Borach)
Albert Brooks (Albert Einstein)
Mel Brooks (Melvin Kaminsky)
Lenny Bruce (Leonard Alfred Schneider)
George Burns (George Birnbaum)
Red Buttons (Aaron Chwatt)
James Caan
Sid Caesar
Eddie Cantor (Edward Israel Iskowitz)
Phoebe Cates (Phoebe Katz)
Jeff Chandler (Ira Grossel)
Andrew Dice Clay (Andrew Silverberg)
Lee J. Cobb (Leo Jacobi)
Howard Cosell (Howard Cohen)
Billy Crystal
Tony Curtis (Bernard Schwartz)
Howard Da Silva (Howard Silverblatt)
Rodney Dangerfield (Jack Cohen)
Neil Diamond
Illeana Douglas
Kirk Douglas (Danielovitch Demsky)
Melvyn Douglas (Melvyn Hesselberg)
Richard Dreyfuss
Bob Dylan (Bob Zimmerman)
Robert Evans (Robert Shapera)
Marty Feldman
Tovah Feldshuh
Norman Fell (Norman Feld)
Harvey Fierstein
Larry Fine (Laurence Feinberg)
Corey Fischer
Eddie Fisher
Al Franken
Leonard Frey
Allen Garfield (Allen Goorwitz)
John Garfield (Julius Garfinkle)
Art Garfunkel
Lorraine Gary (Lorraine Gottfried)
Brad Garrett (Brad Gerstenfeld)
Jack Gilford (Jacob Gellman)
Paul Glaser
Ned Glass
Adam Goldberg
Jeff Goldblum
Barry Gordon
Keith Gordon
Cliff Gorman
Gilbert Gottfried
Elliot Gould
Harold Gould
Lee Grant (Lyova Haskell Rosenthal)
Ellen Greene
Shecky Greene
Andre Gregory
Nick Gregory
Jennifer Grey
Joel Grey
Charles Grodin (Charles Grodinsky)
Ayre Gross
Steve Guttenberg
Buddy Hackett (Leonard Hacker)
Mark Harelik
Aaron Harnik
Lawrence Harvey (Laruschka Mischa Skikne)
Dan Hedaya
Buck Henry (Buck Henry Zuckerman)
Pee Wee Herman (Paul Ruebens)
Stephen Hill (Soloman Krakovsky) - Orthodox!
Marcel Hillaire
Arthur Hiller
Judd Hirsch
Dustin Hoffman
Philip Seymour Hoffman
Judy Holliday (Judith Tuvim)
Oscar Homolka
Michael Hordern
Adam Horwitz
Curly Howard (Jerome Lester Horwitz)
Moe Howard (Moses Horwitz)
Shrimp Howard (Shemp Horwitz)
Lou Jacobi
Sam Jaffe (Shalom Jaffe)
David Janssen (David Harold Meyer)
George Jessel
Al Jolson (Asa Yoelson
Madeline Kahn
Ida Kaminska
Carol Kane
Omri Katz
Andy Kaufman
Julie Kavner
Lainie Kazan (Lainie Levine)
Danny Kaye (David Kaminsky)
Harvey Keitel
Alan King (Irwin Allen Kniberg)
Robert Klein
Sascha Knopf
Jack Klugman
Bernie Kopell
Harvey Korman
Henry Koster (Hermann Kosterlitz)
Jeffery Kramer
Lisa Kudrow
Juliet Landau
Martin Landau
Michael Landon (Eugene Horowitz)
Louise Lasser
Cloris Leachman
Ernest Lehman
Ron Leibman
Sheldon Leonard
Michael Lerner
Sam Levine
Eugene Levy
Jerry Lewis (Joseph Levitch)
Shari Lewis (Shari Hurwitz)
Hal Linden (Harold Lipshitz)
Mark Linn-Baker
Maureen Lipman
Jonathan Lipnicki
Peter Lorre (Laszlo Lowenstein)
Jon Lovitz
Bill Macy (Wolf Marvin Garber)
Howie Mandel
Marcel Marceau
Janet Margolin
Garry Marshall
Chico Marx (Leonard)
Groucho Marx (Julius)
Gummo Marx (Milton)
Harpo Marx (Adolf)
Zeppo Marx (Herbert)
Walter Matthau (Walter Matasschanskayasky)
Elaine May (Elaine Berlin)
Ferdy Mayne
Debra Messing
Bette Midler
Barry Miller
Rick Moranis
Howard Morris
Shelley Morrison (Rachel Mitrani)
Josh Mostel
Zero Mostel
Paul Muni (Muni Weisenfreund)
Alla Nazimova (Mariam Leventon)
Leonard Nimoy
Alan Oppenheimer
Lilli Palmer (Lillie Marie Peiser)
Mandy Patinkin
Sarah Jessica Parker
Rhea Perlman
Natalie Portman
Gilda Radner
Tony Randall (Leonard Rosenberg)
Carl Reiner
Rob Reiner
Paul Reiser
Don Rickles
Peter Riegert
Ron Rifkin
Joan Rivers (Joan Sandra Molinsky)
Edwar G. Robinson (Emmanuel Goldenberg)
Saul Rubinek
Zelda Rubinstein
Winona Ryder (Winona Laura Horowitz)
Mort Sahl
Gene Saks
Adam Sandler
Gary Schandling
David Schwimmer
George Segal
Jerry Seinfeld
William Shatner
Dick Shawn (Richard Schulefand)
Wallace Shawn
Harry Shearer
Anthony Sher
Dinah Shore
Pauly Shore
George Sidney
Silvia Sidney (Sophie Josow)
Simone Signoret
Ron Silver
Jonathan Silverman
Sarah Silverman
Phil Silvers (Philip Silversmith)
Alicia Silverstone
Paul Simon
Rena Sofer
Marla Sokoloff
Daniel Stern
Howard Stern
Ben Stiller
Jerry Stiller
Harold J. Stone
Lee Strassberg
Susan Strassberg
Barbara Streisand
Janet Suzman
Chaim Topol
Michael Tucker
Sophie Tucker (Sophia Abuza)
Anton Walbrook
Eli Wallach
Nancy Walker (Ann Myrtle Swayer)
Sam Wannamaker
Rachel Weisz
Gene Wilder (Jerome Silberman)
Debra Winger
Henry Winkler
Shelley Winters (Shirley Schrift)
Ed Wynn (Isaiah Edwin Leopold)

نصف يهود:-((احد الابوين يهودي ))
Lisa Bonet
Joan Collins
Harry Connick Jr.
Roger Corman
Jamie Lee Curtis
Michael Douglas
Fran Drescher
David Duchovny
Douglas Fairbanks (Douglas Elton Ulman)
Carrie Fisher
Harrison Ford
John Frankenheimer

Paulette Goddard
John Houseman (Jaques Haussmann)
Barbara Hershey
Anthony Newley
Paul Newman
Freddie Prinze
Tanya Roberts
Robbie Robertson
Rob Schneider
Jason Schwartzmann
Erich Von Stroheim (Erich Oswald Stroheim)
Zoe Wanamaker

متحولين الى اليهودية :-

Kate Capshaw
Nell Carter
Sammy Davis Jr.
Anne Meara
Marilyn Monroe
Elizabeth Taylor

هذه قائمة من موقع اخر :-

Anouk Aimee, French actress
Woody Allen, US actor, film director
Jason Alexander, US actor, known from Seinfeld
Patricia Arquette, US actress
Bea Arthur, US actress, known from Maude and The Golden Girls
Ed Asner, US actor
Lauren Bacall, US actress
Barbara Bain, US actress, known from Mission Impossible
Theda Bara, US actress
Richard Belzer, US actor and comedian
Sandra Bernhard, US actress
Sarah Bernhardt, French actress
Joey Bishop, US actor, member of the Rat Pack
Jack Black, US actor and rock musician
Mel Blanc, US cartoon voice actor
Selma Blair, US actress
Yasmine Bleeth, US actress
Orlando Bloom, English Actor {{Father South African Jew}}
Lisa Bonet, US actress, known from The Cosby Show
Ernest Borgnine, US actor
Tom Bosley, US actor
Albert Brooks, US actor
Mel Brooks, US comedian, filmmaker
James Caan, US actor
Dyan Cannon, US actress
Kate Capshaw, US actress
Nell Carter, US actress
Jill Clayburgh, US Oscar-nominated actress
Joan Collins, British actress, known from Dynasty'
Jennifer Connelly, US actress
Billy Crystal, US actor and comedian
Jamie Lee Curtis, US actress
Tony Curtis, US actor
Larry David, US actor and comedy writer
Sammy Davis Jr., US actor and performer (converted)
Kirk Douglas, US actor
Richard Dreyfuss, US actor
Fran Drescher, US actress
Peter Falk, US actor
Itzik Feffer, Russian Yiddish actor
Corey Feldman, US actor
Norman Fell, US actor
Harvey Fierstein, US actor
Carrie Fisher, US actress, star of Star Wars movies
Harrison Ford, US actor, mother is Jewish
Al Franken, US actor and comedy writer
Bonnie Franklin, US actress, known from One Day at a Time
Allen Funt, US TV personality, creator of Candid Camera
Eva Gabor, Hungarian-born US actress
Zsa Zsa Gabor, Hungarian-born US actress
Sarah Michelle Gellar, US actress
Estelle Getty, US actress, known from Golden Girls
Melissa Gilbert, US actress, known from Little House on the Prairie
Judith Godrèche, French actress
Jeff Goldblum, US actor
Seth Green, US actor
Jennifer Grey, US actress
Joel Grey, US actor
Charles Grodin, US actor
Steve Gutenberg, US actor
Nina Hartley, adult film actress
Laurence Harvey, Lithuanian born British actor
Goldie Hawn, US actress
Judd Hirsch, US actor
Dustin Hoffman, US actor
Judy Holliday, US Oscar-winning actress
John Houseman, Romanian-born US actor
Kate Hudson, US actress, daughter of Goldie Hawn
Amy Irving, US actress
Ron Jeremy, US adult film actor
Al Jolson, US singer, actor, early sound film star
Carolyn Jones, US actress, known from The Addams Family
Madeline Kahn, US actress
Gabriel Kaplan, US actor
Andy Kaufman, US actor and comedian
Danny Kaye, US actor, dancer, and singer
Harvey Keitel, US actor
Jack Klugman, US actor
Lisa Kudrow, US actress
Rikki Lake, US actress
Hedy Lamarr, Austrian-born US actress
Michael Landon US Actor
Juliet Landau, US actress
Martin Landau, US actor
Piper Laurie, US actress
Linda Lavin, US actress
Jennifer Jason Leigh, US actress
Gloria Leonard, adult film actress
Eugene Levy, US actor
Al Lewis, US actor, Grandpa on The Munsters
Shari Lewis, US actress, known as companion of Lambchop
Hal Linden, US actor
Jonathan Lipnicki, US child actor
Peggy Lipton, US actress, known from the Mod Squad
Peter Lorre, US actor
Tina Louise, US actress
Jon Lovitz, US actor and comedian
Ali MacGraw, US actress
Marlee Matlin, US Oscar-winning deaf actress
Benjamin Masten, US radio personality (Audience of Two)
Walter Matthau, US actor
Solomon Mikhoels, Russian Yiddish actor
Bette Midler, US singer and actress
Marilyn Monroe, US actress (converted)
Rick Moranis, Canadian actor
Bess Myerson, US TV entertainer
Judd Nelson, US actor, member of the Brat Pack
Anthony Newley, British actor and singer
Laraine Newman, US actress, known from Saturday Night Live
Paul Newman, US actor
Leonard Nimoy, US actor, known from Star Trek
Sharon Osbourne, US actress, wife of Ozzy Osbourne
Gwyneth Paltrow, US actress
Sara Jessica Parker, US actress
Rhea Perlman, US actress
Suzanne Pleshette, US actress
Kevin Pollack, US actor
Tracy Pollan, US actress
Natalie Portman, US actress
Rachel, French actress
Gilda Radner, US actress, known from Saturday Night Live
Harold Ramis, US actor
Harry Reems, adult film actor (born Herbert Streicher)
Roseanne, US actress
Winona Ryder, US actress
Emma Samms, British actress, known from Dynasty
Adam Sandler, US actor/comedian
Laura Schlessinger, US radio personality
William Shatner, Canadian actor, known from Star Trek
Ally Sheedy, US actress
Dinah Shore, US actress
Simone Signoret, French actress
Jaclyn Smith, US actress, original Charlie's Angels
Rena Sofer, US actress
Annie Sprinkle, adult film actress (born Ellen Steinberg)
Howard Stern, US radio personality
Barbara Streisand, US actress and singer
David Suchet, British actor
Elizabeth Taylor, British-born US actress (converted)
Barbara Walters, US TV news personality
Rachel Weisz, British actress

مخرجون يهود:-

Jim Abrahams
Darren Aronofsky
Ralph Bakshi
Burt Balaban
Peter Bogdanovich
Harold Clurman
Joel and Ethan Coen
George Cukor
Robert Epstein
Max Fleischer
Richard Fleischer
Melvin Frank
William Friedkin
Larry Gelbart
Amos Gitai
Menahem Golan
Keith Gordon
Arthur Hiller
Jeremy Paul Kagan
Aviva Kempner
Irwin Kershner
Stanley Kramer
Stanley Kubrick
Fritz Lang
Norman Lear
Mervyn LeRoy
Barry Levinson
Dani Levy
Ernst Lubitsch
Sidney Lumet
David Mamet (Richard Weisz)
Joseph Mankiewicz
Joe May (Joseph Mandel)
Nicholas Meyer
Elijah Moshinsky
Paul Mazursky
Max Ophuls (Maximilian Oppenheimer)
Frank Oz (Frank Ozkerwitz)
Alan J. Pakula
Larry Peerce
Roman Polanski
Sidney Pollack
Abraham Polonsky

Otto Preminger
Max Reinhardt (Maximillian Goldman)
Martin Ritt
Stuart Rosenberg
Herbert Ross
Robert Rossen
Boris Sagal
John Schlesinger
Melville Shavelson
Don Siegel
Joan Macklin Silver
Robert Siodmark
Todd Solondz
Steven Speilberg
Billy Wilder
Herbert Wise
Robert Wise
William Wyler
Robert Zemeckis
Fred Zinneman
David Zucker
Jerry Zucker